
Quote on Stewardship from Stansbury Consulting
Earning the Right to Ask Before You Ask Again
By Alyce Lee Stansbury, CFRE, Notes on Nonprofits
Every fall, nonprofit organizations pour their energy into various campaigns, strategies, and special events to ask for donations. Appeal letters get drafted, campaigns get scheduled, boards get briefed on their fundraising role. But before a single year-end appeal goes out, there’s a question worth asking first:
Have you told donors about the impact of their last gift?
It’s easy to skip this step when the calendar is compressed and the pressure to hit a year-end goal is real. While the data show giving clusters heavily at year-end, the decision-making starts much earlier.
That means stewardship isn’t the “nice to have” that happens after a fundraising event or campaign. It’s the foundation of successful fundraising programs designed to build trusted, long-term donor relationships.
Successful Fundraising Is More Than the Ask
Too many organizations think of fundraising as a single action of asking for the gift. In reality, a successful fundraising program rests on three distinct disciplines working together:
- Acquisition: bringing new donors into the organization for the first time.
- Retention: keeping those donors giving year after year.
- Stewardship: thanking, reporting to and genuinely engaging donors so the relationship deepens over time.
One of best ways to visualize fundraising without stewardship is a leaky bucket. According to the Association of Fundraising Professional Fund Raising Effectiveness Project, the average donor retention rate of first-time donors is 18% to 20%. That means for every 100 new donors who make a gift, 3 out of 4 never give again. Organizations who only invest in acquisition are constantly refilling their bucket, investing time and money to find and interest new donors, only to lose them before its time to ask again.
If your fundraising strategy is focused almost entirely on acquisition, it’s worth pausing to ask why. Often, it’s because acquisition is measurable and visible while stewardship can feel harder to quantify. A tool to measure stewardship results is tracking your donor retention rate which is the number of donors who gave last year and this year divided by the total number of donors. Another metric is the number of first time donors who make a second gift.
Stewardship Made Easy
Stewardship begins with a timely, personalized thank you letter. Acknowledging the gift is the first step towards building trust between your organization and people who donate to your mission. Make time to write a new, heartfelt thank you letter that focuses on what the donor’s gift makes possible. To help you avoid using trite phrases and jargon, imagine you are writing to your favorite aunt or close friend. Although the gift is important, this technique will remind you it’s the donor and your relationship with them that matters most.
Before your year-end campaign gets underway, use this stewardship checklist to assess whether your organization has:
- Thanked donors promptly and personally for their most recent gift, not just an automated receipt.
- Reported back on the impact of their gift that shows donors, in concrete terms, what their giving made possible.
- Reached out without asking for anything. This can be a phone call, invitation for a tour or behind-the-scenes event, a handwritten thank you note with a short update, or maybe even a visit.
For board members who are reluctant to ask for money, stewardship is a great way for them to support the fundraising effort. Board member calls, notes, and thank you visits are a great way to surprise and delight donors.
The Cost of Skipping Stewardship
When stewardship gets skipped, the effect shows up exactly where organizations can least afford it: in donor retention rates, average gift size, and the interest of loyal donors to consider a larger, more transformational gift.
Donors who are asked for a gift without ever being thanked are far more likely to lapse, no matter how compelling this year’s appeal. Instead, donors who feel genuinely seen and thanked are far more likely to renew their support and increase it over time. I call this the “show-me-that-you-know-me” approach.
It’s a good reminder your most important prospective donor isn’t a strange, it’s a donor who gave last year. Their willingness to give again is directly impacted by how they were treated after their last gift and in the months since then.
Build Stewardship into Your Plan
Here are three ways to build stewardship into your fundraising plan:
- A thank-you call scheduled within 48 hours of a gift.
- An impact report sent quarterly or bi-annually.
- A board member assigned to reach out to a handful of donors each month.
Before your year-end campaign launches, consider these three questions:
- Who made a gift in the last six months and hasn’t heard from your organization since?
- How can we involve board members in nurturing donor relationships?
- What would it take to make sure every current donor feels thanked and informed before they are asked again?
A strong year-end fundraising campaign isn’t built in November; it starts now with an intentional effort to let donors know their gifts make a difference.
Stansbury Consulting is celebrating 20 years of helping nonprofit organizations build sustainable fundraising programs. If your organization needs help implementing a stewardship program and improving year-end fundraising results, we can help.
