AI Illustration of a board of directors doing fall planning at a conference table.

AI Generated Image

Ghosting Donors, Frightful Fundraising and Year-End Delights

By Alyce Lee Stansbury, CFRE, Notes on Nonprofits


Feeling bewitched and bewildered about your organization’s year-end fundraising plan?
Before the ghosts and goblins arrive, here’s my annual Halloween-themed roundup of frights, sights and delights to help your organization raise more money between now and the end of the year.

SIGHTS

Let’s start by creepin’ it real with four fundraising trends to strengthen fundraising results.

  1. Bequests are on the rise. Charitable bequests increased almost 20% in 2025 according to Giving USA. Don’t turn your back on legacy giving. Letting supporters know they can leave a legacy with a bequest or planned gift on your website, newsletter, and other donor communication is an easy way to start.
  2. GivingTuesday is December 1. This annual online day of giving is an effective strategy to attract first-time donors and launch or grow a recurring giving program. Find a donor willing to match every gift to help your campaign be a thriller!
  3. AI sounds spooky. It may feel like hocus pocus, but artificial intelligence is transforming how nonprofits analyze data, stretch limited resources, and maximize impact. Use AI to make your work more efficient, not replace the human connection that builds trust and inspires people to give at higher levels.
  4. Focus on retention. While recent trends show charitable giving remains strong, donor retention is the key to long-term fundraising sustainability. Acquiring a new donor costs five times more than retaining an existing donor. October is a great time to reconnect with donors who care about your mission before asking for a year-end gift.

FRIGHTS

Here are six frightening fundraising practices to avoid this giving season.

  1. Ghosting donors. A donor makes a gift and hears nothing until you ask for another gift. Eeek – that’s a gruesome sight! To avoid the fundraising version of a zombie apocalypse, send prompt acknowledgements, meaningful updates, and genuine gratitude all year-round. It’s not too late to start now.
  2. Fear of asking. Expecting people to give without asking is a real house of horrors. Donors who care need to understand what you do, who you serve, why it matters, and how their gift makes a difference. Don’t let the fear of hearing “no” stop you from giving people an opportunity to say “yes.”
  3. Too afraid to fundraise. Too often, board members are lurking in the shadows, afraid to ask for money. Invite them to make an introduction, secure a speaking opportunity, call or visit a donor to say thank you. Helping board members find their niche in the fundraising process can help take the fear out of fundraising.
  4. One-size-fits-all approach. A longtime donor, first-time donor, volunteer, monthly giver and lapsed supporter don’t have the same relationship with your organization. Avoid the one-size-fits-all approach by segmenting and personalizing donor communication based on their relationship with the organization and giving history.
  5. Not testing the donation page. Nothing strikes terror in the heart of a fundraiser more than making it hard for donors to give. Test the donation page on your website on a phone, tablet, and computer. Check every link and complete a gift yourself. Make sure the acknowledgement process works. Don’t wait until GivingTuesday or your year-end campaign to discover a problem.
  6. No stewardship plan. Research reveals 81% of first-time donors never make a second gift. Sending a generic receipt or one-time form letter will doom your fundraising results to a similar fate. Decide now how donors will be thanked, by when, by whom, and how you will nurture the relationship in the new year.

DELIGHTS

Here are five fundraising treats (no tricks!) to show donors you care.

  1. Give the gift of clarity. Got a few zombie board members sleepwalking through their board service? Board members are far more likely to help when they know exactly what is expected of them. Create a short list of tangible actions for them, and turn “I don’t know who to ask” into meaningful participation.
  2. Pick up the phone. Emails get reactions, phone calls start conversations. Calling donors without asking them for money is an opportunity to learn why they care about your mission. This is the first step to building authentic relationships.
  3. Host a thank-a-thon. November is an ideal time to host a dedicated event in which board and staff members call donors, volunteers and other supporters for one reason only: to say thank you. This process not only nurtures donor relationships, it engages and energizes board members.
  4. Making giving easy. A donor who cares enough to give today may be willing to support your mission every month. Make recurring giving visible, simple, and explain what their sustaining support makes possible.
  5. Celebrate philanthropy. National Philanthropy Day is November 15 and an opportunity to recognize the donors, volunteers, board members, businesses, and community partners who help make your mission possible. Contact your local Association of Fundraising Professionals chapter for more information on a celebration near you.

Fundraising does not have to be scary! As Halloween approaches, leverage the sights, avoid the frights, and implement delights to help every donor feel seen and grow fundraising results to achieve your mission.

Stansbury Consulting is celebrating 20 years of helping nonprofit organizations build sustainable fundraising programs.  If your organization needs help improving year-end fundraising efforts, we can help. www.StansburyConsulting.com

Recommend
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIN
Share
Tagged in